Our Favorite Stories of 2018

Adam Przybyl, Editor-in-chief

Emeline Posner, Managing Editor

Sam Stecklow, Managing Editor

Jasmine Mithani, Deputy Editor

Two biographies go beyond symbolism in the life of Harold Washington
By Christian Belanger

 

This review made me weep, in the good way. I don’t know if Christian is a stellar fact-checker, a brilliant writer or a good reader of the two books he discusses; and my guess is he’s a bit of all three. Here he captured so accurately detail for detail of all the moving parts involved in electing Mayor Harold Washington and the council wars that ensued following his untimely death.

Christian’s account transported me immediately back to my political coming of age, which was during Harold Washington’s first campaign thirty-five years ago. Voting for “Harold” as was customary to call him, was my very first vote ever. But not only did I vote, I was part of the movement that made him a candidate. I was part of the ranks that tirelessly volunteered at his campaign offices. My mom became a deputy registrar to help increase the number of registered voters. I celebrated in the Washington victory. I mourned, and in a way am still mourning Washington’s untimely death.

The way Christian captures the moments so precisely, is what journalism and reporting are, particularly because he would have no way of knowing any of the details he chronicles considering he wasn’t even born! This is journalism and reporting. As you know (and much likely to everyone’s annoyance) my litmus test for fact-checking is not digging up some corroborating previously published document, but instead an obstinate “Because I was there and I know.” This piece passes all of “my” fact-checking standards and it may help to motivate voters and potential voters to whittle down the ridiculously long twenty-one list of mayoral hopefuls into one electable candidate. – Nicole Bond, Stage & Screen Editor

Losing Harper High School
In a good school-bad school paradigm, Harper High School’s rich hundred-plus-year history risks being forgotten
By Eleanore Catolico

 

 This piece did a fantastic job in sharing what exactly made Harper more than just a school—despite years of disinvestment from Chicago Public Schools, Harper served as a community anchor for generations of Englewood residents who found a family in their classmates and teachers. Eleanore did a fantastic job in finding and interviewing a wide range of Harper alumni (and a current student) and weaving their stories into the larger history of years of CPS disinvestment in South Side high schools and the recent CPS decision to close four historic Englewood high schools to make way for a new facility.

After the piece was released, numerous Harper alumni began sharing their own stories in the comment section, showing that Harper still remains a deeply loved institution, and that there are still so many stories about Harper that need to be told. Alongside the Weekly’s incredible Robeson Project, “Losing Harper High School” exemplifies everything we believe in at the Weekly: journalism that serves neighborhoods, their people, and their histories. – Rachel Kim, Education Editor

Surfing Through the Sludge
Lake Michigan surfers brave freezing cold—and toxic—waters, while the Surfrider Foundation sues to clean them up
By Rebecca Fanning

 

This piece explores Northwest Indiana’s surf culture: why people keep surfing in a freezing lake, how people are responding to recent industrial pollution, and the tension for surfers who want action against polluters, but also don’t want their beach shut down. Every issue of the Weekly has a story or two about something I never knew existed, but this one stands out as one of the year’s most unusual, and it does an excellent job of nimbly covering complex legal and health issues in a way that highlights the impacts of those issues on local residents. – Sam Joyce, Director of Fact-checking

Cognitive Dissidence
Chicago’s abolitionists make space for conversation after the Van Dyke trial
By Christian Belanger

In the wake of the Van Dyke trial, the Weekly wanted to provide meaningful coverage that didn’t simply rehash the traumatic facts of Laquan McDonald’s death. Abolitionism is a key part of Chicago’s, and the South Side’s, activist ecosystem, but those voices were missing in mainstream conversations. Christian tapped into this network to hear their perspectives, exploring the tension between the astonishment and peace brought by the conviction—the first of its kind in Chicago—and what it means to perpetuate the incarceration state that continues to inflict violence upon Black people. This story exemplifies the purpose of the Weekly; it was published nearly a month after the trial, documenting how communities continued to react to the news in the weeks after the verdict, versus stopping the story mere hours or days after. It was intentional: the Weekly looked for local voices and used its platform to elevate them. Finally, it continued to challenge the reader to answer—after the media excitement over the verdict faded away—in the words of abolitionist Trina Reynolds-Tyler, “What is justice for Laquan McDonald?” – Jasmine Mithani, Deputy Editor

God’s Little Acres
First Presbyterian Church has fostered community gardens since the nineteenth century. Its now-former pastor nearly put an end to that
By Emeline Posner

 

This past spring, the pastor of Woodlawn’s First Presbyterian sent out a letter announcing that the two community gardens affiliated with the church would soon be shut down. After a concerted media campaign, the gardens were saved and the pastor was fired (for, officially, another reason), but the question of what had happened in the first place remained shrouded in mystery. With this story, Emeline delved into the long history of community gardening in Woodlawn, and did more than anyone else to show how the relationship between church and neighborhood residents has evolved over the years, and where it is now. It’s an instance of the kind of journalism the Weekly does better than almost anyone else in the city: thoughtful, beautiful writing about issues that would otherwise pass most people by. – Christian Belanger, Senior Editor

Kapano, In Their Own World
The nineteen-year-old South Shore native sits down with the Weekly to discuss donuts, dreams, and art
By Juhi Gupta

 

I really enjoyed this story about South Side artist Kopano because it was simple in style but explored the complexities behind identity and branding as an artist. Kopano seems to be at a crossroad in terms of their artistic career, and I think their vulnerability to admit this is important because it turns what can appear to be a difficult period into one of exploration. Kopano also talks about navigating love in queer relationships and speaks about the need to define their own rules and “put themselves in situations where they feel uncomfortable in order to grow.” This is great advice for relationships and beyond! – Roderick Sawyer, Visual Arts Editor

Through the Cracks
By Nicole Bond

 

At the Weekly, we publish a lot of important features and investigations into issues facing the South Side, such as evictions and a lack of affordable housing. But I believe a crucial part of our work—and a crucial part of being by and for the South Side—is illuminating how these issues actually affect people’s lives and providing a forum for personal reflection. I think Nicole’s essay is a great example of this—she beautifully writes about her own experience and illuminates the deficits of housing services along the way. A lot of journalism about housing would gloss over how dealing with this affects you personally, but this essay drives right at the heart of it. One of my absolute favorite things the Weekly has ever published. – Mari Cohen, Senior Editor

The Solution to “Food Deserts” Isn’t Just Food
We need to talk racism, segregation, and income disparity, too
By Dejah Powell

In our 2018 Food Issue, Dejah Powell challenged readers to move beyond the term “food desert,” a term which, Dejah writes, does not adequately capture the complexity of food accessibility in communities of color. Integrating personal reflections and research from her senior thesis, Dejah explains why “food apartheid” is a better and more just term: because it suggests responsibility for such conditions can be found among those who set and implement policy on labor, housing, development, and more. The conditions for food scarcity in communities of color are connected “not only to segregation, but also to the roots of capitalism and racism that run deep within American society,” she writes. “We will not solve the food accessibility issue with just placing grocery stores throughout the city….[We also need to] fight against severe segregation and push for a higher minimum wage.” It’s a pressing call for residents, journalists, researchers, and politicians alike to rethink solutions to food scarcity, and to reconsider the language we use when we talk about it. – Emeline Posner, Managing Editor

Meet Ricard(ito) Gamboa
A look into the artist, activist, and academic’s “alternative cultural ecology”
By Itzel Blancas

Ricardo Gamboa’s recent play with Free Street Theater, Meet Juan(ito) Doe, is deeply rooted in their communities on the South Side. Inspired by stories collected from members of Chicago’s Mexican community, staged in the new Storyfront theater in Back of the Yards, the play is first and foremost for the people whose experiences it seeks to reflect. Itzel Blancas’s piece about the show is not just a review; it’s a beautiful meditation on what that kind of space feels like, how it’s made, and why it matters, and an in-depth profile of a creator whose work deserves much more thoughtful coverage. And it exemplifies how even in arts coverage, the Weekly seeks to look deeper and, like Meet Juan(ito) Doe, write from and for the communities it writes about. – Olivia Stovicek, Senior Editor

Why Is CPS Closing NTA?
Before NTA conversion proposal, emails reveal multiyear history to the plans for a new neighborhood high school
By Daniel Moattar

A follow-up to a 2017 story on CPS’s plan to convert NTA into a high school, this story focuses on the intersecting needs of Chicago communities: Chinatown families who’ve been seeking a neighborhood high school for years, an influential South Loop community association, and the parents of NTA students fighting to keep their elementary school open. The story features many of the typical Chicago issues—segregation, lack of transparency at CPS, and behind-the-scenes conversations between aldermen and a select group of influential community members. At its heart is a question many of the Weekly’s most powerful stories ask again and again: who has the say in our communities? – Adam Przybyl, Editor-in-chief